Redemption Periods Are Why Your LTV Is Lower Here
Wisconsin forecloses through the courts, and it layers something on top that most states do not: statutory redemption periods during which a borrower can reclaim the property after judgment.
The length varies with the circumstances of the foreclosure and the remedies the lender elects, but the effect on lending is consistent. A Wisconsin foreclosure takes materially longer to resolve than one in a power-of-sale state, and that time is capital the investor cannot recover or redeploy.
Non-QM investors price it directly. The result shows up as lower maximum LTVs and higher reserve requirements than the same borrower would see in Tennessee or Georgia. That is not something a better rate quote fixes; it is priced into the state.
Plan on putting more down in Wisconsin, and understand that when a lender comes back at 75 percent where you expected 80, the redemption period is why. What a broker can do is find the investor whose Wisconsin adjustment is smallest, because the size of that adjustment varies meaningfully between shelves.
The Lenders
Select Home Loans
Select Home Loans is a Non-QM mortgage broker (NMLS #2384002) writing 1099 investor loans across Wisconsin. The LTV variation described above is exactly why shopping one shelf is insufficient here — and appetite for Milwaukee’s older duplex stock and for Northwoods seasonal property varies just as much.
We quote DSCR and bank statement alternatives alongside the 1099 program so you can compare paths on the same property.
Get a quote · (888) 550-3296
Other lenders worth calling — listed in no particular order:
Capital Home Mortgage Wisconsin Wisconsin operations across 1099, bank statement, asset, and DSCR programs.
Angel Oak Mortgage Solutions One of the largest dedicated Non-QM investors nationally, with a purpose-built 1099 income program. Reached through a broker.
Griffin Funding Publishes qualifying on 90 to 100 percent of gross 1099 income, 620 minimum credit, and loan amounts to $4 million.
Newfi Lending A Non-QM lender covering Wisconsin with DSCR, bank statement, and self-employed programs, with in-house underwriting.
Deephaven Mortgage A long-established Non-QM lender with DSCR and alternative documentation programs.
NASB (North American Savings Bank) Among the longest-running alternative documentation programs in the country, with a 1099-NEC based option and a Midwest base.
Wisconsin’s local Non-QM bench is underrepresented in these results. Verify current licensure before relying on any listing see the disclaimer at the end of this page.
Dairy and Agricultural Income Documents Differently
Wisconsin’s agricultural economy produces the same problem Iowa’s does, and the answer is the same: check which document actually carries your income before you choose a product.
A dairy operation moves substantial money through its accounts milk checks, livestock sales, custom work and then equipment depreciation, feed, veterinary costs, and land rent absorb it. The taxable figure that emerges bears no relationship to the operation’s capacity.
But much of that income may not appear on 1099 forms in any meaningful amount, because it arrives through cooperatives and processors in varying forms. If your 1099 totals are small relative to your actual receipts, a bank statement program reading deposits will serve you far better than a 1099 program and an asset-based program against owned farmland is worth asking about too.
Whatever the product, run twenty-four months. Milk prices and crop years vary for reasons outside your control, and two years gives an underwriter something to average against.
How Qualifying Works
A 1099 loan qualifies you on income documented on your 1099 forms rather than the net profit shown after deductions.
Programs split into two camps. Some apply 90 percent or more of gross 1099 income with no expense deduction. Others apply an expense factor of 10 to 25 percent first.
On $180,000 of annual 1099 income:
| Method | Qualifying income |
|---|---|
| 90% of gross | $162,000/yr — $13,500/mo |
| Gross less 20% expense factor | $144,000/yr — $12,000/mo |
| Net profit from your tax return | frequently under $80,000 |
Given the lower LTVs available here, you need every dollar of qualifying income the program will give you to make up the difference in down payment. Push on the expense factor.
Model the payment with our mortgage calculators.
The two-year self-employment history requirement is separate from the two-year income lookback. Ask about both.
Wisconsin’s 1099 Population
Construction and specialty trades, working a genuinely short building season and an old housing stock.
Dairy and agricultural operators across the western and central counties the profile above.
Manufacturing and industrial contractors around the Fox Valley and the Milwaukee industrial corridor.
Healthcare contracting around the Madison and Milwaukee medical systems.
Owner-operator trucking along the I-94 corridor.
Tourism and outdoor recreation operators in Door County and the Northwoods, with income concentrated into short seasons.
Wisconsin Investment Markets
Milwaukee carries the bulk of investor inventory and a distinctive asset: an unusually deep stock of duplexes and side-by-side two-family homes. Combined rents across both units are what make DSCR work in Milwaukee a single-family purchase at the same price frequently will not clear the ratio, while a duplex will. If you want DSCR here, two-family is the way.
Madison commands higher values driven by university and state government employment, with tighter ratios and strong long-term demand.
Fox Valley Appleton, Oshkosh, Green Bay offers solid rent-to-price ratios with a manufacturing employment base.
Door County and the Northwoods are seasonal short-term rental markets. Annualized rent from a summer-weighted or winter-weighted property gets discounted, which is when the 1099 path beats DSCR. Several jurisdictions regulate short-term rentals; verify the specific address.
Smaller cities — Racine, Kenosha, Janesville, Eau Claire — offer lower entry prices where loan minimums begin to bind.
Other Wisconsin Specifics
Older housing stock. Milwaukee’s duplex inventory is largely pre-1940, bringing lead disclosure obligations and frequent deferred-maintenance flags — knob-and-tube, older heating, foundation and porch condition.
Cold-weather condition items. Freeze-thaw damage, roof loading, and heating system age surface in appraisals routinely. Where the landlord pays heat, that cost enters the DSCR calculation directly and it is not small here.
Property taxes are relatively high and vary by municipality and school district. Because taxes sit inside both DTI and DSCR, pull the actual bill.
Milwaukee rental registration and inspection requirements apply in some circumstances. Confirm compliance status before applying on a refinance of an existing rental.
Investment Property Terms
- Down payment: expect the higher end of 20–25 percent, and sometimes more, given the redemption period
- Credit: 620 floor at most investors; real improvements at 680, 700, 740
- Reserves: 6–12 months PITIA, trending toward the top of the range here
- Prepayment penalties: common on investment property, typically 1–3 years, often buyable at a quarter to a half point
Compare with our purchase loan options and refinance loan options.
1099 or DSCR?
Use DSCR on Milwaukee duplexes and Fox Valley rentals, where rents genuinely cover the payment after Wisconsin’s tax burden.
Use a 1099 loan on Madison single-family where ratios tighten, on Door County and Northwoods seasonal property, on anything below a DSCR investor’s loan minimum, on properties needing work first, or where you are also buying a primary residence.
If you already hold Wisconsin rentals, a DSCR refinance works well on the two-family stock.
Questions to Ask
- What maximum LTV can you actually reach on a Wisconsin investment property? (Ask this first.)
- Do you qualify on gross 1099 income, or apply an expense factor?
- My income is agricultural should this be a 1099, bank statement, or asset-based file?
- What is your appetite for pre-1940 Milwaukee duplexes?
- How do you treat seasonal rent in Door County or the Northwoods?
- Can you quote DSCR on the same property?
More from Select Home Loans: DSCR loans · DSCR refinance · Learning Center · About Select
Disclaimer
The lenders described on this page are listed in no particular order. Select Home Loans appears first because we publish this page and originate these loans; we have a commercial interest in this category. No lender listed has paid for placement.
This page reflects our opinion based on publicly available information at the time of writing. It is general information, not a recommendation, an endorsement, or an offer of credit. Lender programs, guidelines, licensure, pricing, and availability change frequently and without notice, and nothing here guarantees that any lender is currently licensed in Wisconsin, currently offers the program described, or will approve your file.
Foreclosure procedure, redemption rights, municipal requirements, and tax rates vary and change; verify independently and consult a Wisconsin attorney on procedural questions. Consult a licensed mortgage professional and where appropriate a tax advisor, attorney, or financial advisor before making any borrowing decision. Verify any lender’s licensure through NMLS Consumer Access at nmlsconsumeraccess.org.
Select Home Loans, NMLS #2384002. Equal Housing Opportunity.
